skip to main content




Puzzle ZIHG 



??

A Proof That 2 = 1:
1. let x=y
           X = Y

2. multiply by x on both sides
         X*X = XY

3. subtract y*y from both sides
   X*X - Y*Y = XY - Y*Y

4. factorise
  (X+Y)(X-Y) = Y(X-Y)

5. divide by (x-y) on both sides
       (X+Y) = Y

6. replace x with y
         Y+Y = Y

7. factorise
          2Y = Y

8. divide by y on both sides
           2 = 1

Where lies the flaw in the logic?

workings hide answer print

Share link: www.brainbashers.com/puzzle/zihg

Answer
On line 4 we are dividing both sides by (X-Y).

But we know that X = Y, so X - Y = 0.

We are not allowed to divide by zero as this is meaningless.

 

Note: BrainBashers has a Dark Mode setting.