Bank Robbery #2 – Logic Puzzles
After a local bank robbery, four suspects were interviewed. Below is a summary of their statements.
The police know that each of them told the truth in one of the statements, but lied in the other.
From this information, can you tell who committed the crime?
Ashley said:
It wasn't Drew
It wasn't Billie
Billie said:
It wasn't Casey
It was Drew
Casey said:
It was Ashley
It wasn't Drew
Drew said:
It was Casey
It wasn't Ashley
Puzzle Copyright © Kevin Stone
workings hint hide answer print
www.brainbashers.com
Answer
Billie robbed the bank.
Reasoning
We know that each of them told the truth in one of the statements and lied in the other.
So according to Ashley, as one of the statements is false, it must have been either Drew or Billie.
If it was Drew, then Billie's statements would both be true, which isn't allowed.
Therefore, it was Billie, which agrees with Casey and Drew's statements.